Thursday, March 31, 2011

DR 25/2010 - A bill that would have been detrimental to workers have been defeated..

Thankfully, the Malaysian governments attempt to legalize 'outsourcing' agents/companies, and to also make them employers of these workers - not the company where this workers will be working for did not succeed. This Bill to amend the Employment Act 1955, that was tabled in July 2010 was withdrawn in October 2010.

As usual, when the Bill was tabled a lot of attention was focused on Part XVA Sexual Harassment, but thankfully Malaysians also saw the things that would have brought in 'silently' to the detriment of all workers.

Note, that whilst the victims of 'outsourcing' agents/companies initially when it started around 2005, but today local workers are also being victimized. When one gets supplied by these outsourcing agents, the companies claim that you are not their workers....and workers will lose many of rights and benefits now existing under the employment Act. These workers will not be allowed to be part of the union in the company, or even benefit from the collective agreement unions make with employers. Why? Because you are not an employee of the company - but an employee of an outsourcing agent.

Our unions are organized according to sectors - but many of these outsourcing agents supply workers to so many different sectors.


DR 25/2010

A BILL

intituled

An Act to amend the Employment Act 1955.

ENACTED by the Parliament of Malaysia as follows:

1. Short title and commencement

(1) This Act may be cited as the Employment (Amendment) Act 2010.

(2) This Act comes into operation on a date to be appointed by the Minister by notification in the Gazette, and the Minister may appoint different dates for the coming into operation of different provisions of this Act.

2. Amendment of section 2

The Employment Act 1955 [Act 265], which is referred to as the "principal Act" in this Act, is amended in subsection 2(1):-

(a) in the definition of "confinement", by substituting for the word "twenty-eight" the word "twenty-two";

(b) in the definition of "constructional contractor", by substituting for the word "assigns" the word "assignees";

(c) by inserting after the definition of "contractor" the following definition:

' "contractor for labour" means a person who contracts with a principal, contractor or sub-contractor to supply the labour required for the execution of the whole or any part of any work which a contractor or sub-contractor has contracted to carry out for a principal or contractor, as the case may be;’;

(d) in the definition of "employer", by inserting after the words "first mentioned person" the words "or any person who supplies or undertakes to supply any employee engaged by him to any employer, principal, contractor or sub-contractor";

(e) by inserting after the definition of "medical officer" the following definition:

' "Minister" means the Minister charged with the responsibility for human resources;’;

(f) by inserting after the definition of "registered medical practitioner" the following definition:

' "sexual harassment" means any unwanted conduct of a sexual nature, whether verbal, non-verbal, visual, gestural or physical, directed at a person which is offensive or humiliating or is a threat to his well-being, arising out of and in the course of his employment;’; and

(g) by deleting the definition of "sub-contractor for labour".

3. Amendment of section 4

Section 4 of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "under section 69 or section 73" the words "or decision under section 69, 69B, 69C or 73".

4. Amendment of Part V

Part V of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the heading "RELATING TO THE TRUCK SYSTEM" the heading "SYSTEM OF PAYMENT OF WAGES".

5. Amendment of section 25A

Paragraph 25A(1)(a) of the principal Act is amended by inserting after the words "the Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989 [Act 372]" the words "or any licensed financial institution or other institutions approved by Bank Negara Malaysia".

6. New section 25B

The principal Act is amended by inserting after section 25A the following section:-

"Payment of wages of domestic servant

25B. Notwithstanding sections 25 and 25A, the wages of a domestic servant shall be paid into an account in the name of the domestic servant at a bank or finance company licensed under the Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989 or any licensed financial institution or other institutions approved by Bank Negara Malaysia:

Provided that the Director General may, on an application made to him by an employer of the domestic servant, exempt the employer in writing from the application of this section.".

7. Amendment of section 31

Section 31 of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "sub-contractor for labour", wherever they appear, the words "contractor for labour".

8. Amendment of Part VII

Part VII of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the heading "CONTRACTORS AND PRINCIPALS" the heading "CONTRACTORS, PRINCIPALS AND CONTRACTORS FOR LABOUR".

9. New section 33A

The principal Act is amended by inserting after section 33 the following section: "Information relating to supply of employees 33A. (1) A contractor for labour who intends to supply or undertakes to supply any employee shall register with the Director General in the prescribed form.

(2) If a contractor for labour referred to in subsection (1) supplies any employee, he shall keep or maintain one or more registers containing information regarding each employee supplied by him and shall make such registers available for inspection.

(3) A contractor for labour who:-

(a) fails to register with the Director General as required under subsection (1); or

(b) fails to keep or maintain any register, or make available any register for inspection as required under subsection (2),

commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding fifty thousand ringgit.".

10. Amendment of section 37

Section 37 of the principal Act is amended by inserting after subsection (3) the following subsection:

"(4) Any employer who terminates the service of a female employee during the period in which she is entitled to maternity leave commits an offence:

Provided that for the purposes of this section, such termination shall not include termination on the ground of retirement, resignation tendered by such employee or on the ground of closure of the employer’s business.".

11. Amendment of section 40

Section 40 of the principal Act is amended by substituting for subsection (3) the following subsection:

"(3) Notwithstanding subsections (1) and (2), any employer who terminates the service of a female employee who fails to give such notice of her maternity leave during the period in which she is entitled to maternity leave commits an offence.".

12. Amendment of section 42

Subsection 42(2) of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "a female employee is dismissed from her employment" the words "the service of a female employee is terminated".

13. Amendment of section 60

Paragraph 60(3)(b) of the principal Act is amended by inserting after the word "monthly" the words "or weekly".

14. Amendment of section 60D

Section 60D of the principal Act is amended:-

(a) in subsection (1):-

(i) by substituting for the words "a this" the words "at his"; and

(ii) in paragraph (a):-

(A) by substituting for the word "ten" the word "eleven";

(B) by substituting for the word "four" the word "five";

(C) in subparagraph (iii), by deleting the word "and" appearing at the end of the subparagraph; and

(D) by inserting after subparagraph (iv) the following subparagraph:

"(v) Malaysia Day; and"; and

(b) in paragraph (3)(aaa), by deleting the word "in" appearing after the word "referred".

15. Amendment of section 60I

Section 60I of the principal Act is amended:-

(a) in subsection (1C), by inserting after the words "on a daily" the words "or an hourly"; and

(b) in subsection (1D), by inserting after the words "on a daily" the words "or an hourly".

16. Substitution of section 60K

The principal Act is amended by substituting for section 60K the following section:

"Notice to employ foreign employees and submission of returns

60K. (1) An employer who intends to employ a foreign employee shall give notice of his intention to do so in the prescribed form to the Director General.

(2) The Director General may, at any time after receipt of a notice under subsection (1), request the employer to furnish him within the period specified in the request or within any extended period of time, further information or particulars on the notice.

(3) Upon receipt of the notice or further information or particulars under subsection (2), the Director General may impose conditions on the employer relating to the employment of the foreign employee as he thinks fit.

(4) An employer who:-

(a) employs a foreign employee without giving a notice as required under subsection (1);

(b) fails to furnish any further information or particulars as may be required by the Director General under subsection (2);

(c) gives notice under subsection (1) containing any false or misleading particulars; or

(d) gives any false or misleading further information or particulars under subsection (2),

commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding fifty thousand ringgit.

(5) An employer who employs a foreign employee shall, within fourteen days of the employment, furnish the Director General with the particulars of the foreign employee by forwarding the particulars to the nearest office of the Director General in such manner as may be determined by the Director General.

(6) An employer or any specified class of employers, whenever required to do so by the Director General, shall furnish returns of particulars relating to the employment of a foreign employee in such manner and at such intervals as the Director General may direct.

(7) An employer who contravenes subsections (5) or (6) commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding fifty thousand ringgit.".

17. Amendment of section 60O

Section 60O of the principal Act is amended:-

(a) in the shoulder note, by inserting after the words "Permanent resident" the words "or domestic servant"; and

(b) by inserting after the word "Malaysia" the words "or a domestic servant".

18. Amendment of section 69

Subsection 69(2) of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "sub-contractor for labour" the words "contractor for labour".

19. Amendment of section 73

Subsection 73(1) of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "sub-contractor for labour" and "subcontractor for labour" the words "contractor for labour".

20. Amendment of section 79

Subsection 79(1) of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "Electricity Act 1949 [Act 116]" the words "Electricity Supply Act 1990 [Act 447]".

21. New Part XVA

The principal Act is amended by inserting after Part XV the following Part:

"PART XVA

SEXUAL HARASSMENT

Interpretation

81A. For the purposes of this Part, "complaint of sexual harassment" means any complaint relating to sexual harassment made:-

(i) by an employee against another employee;

(ii) by an employee against any employer;

(iii) by an employer against another employer; or

(iv) by an employer against an employee.

Establishment of procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment and inquiry into such complaints

81B. (1) An employer shall establish procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment.

(2) Any person may make a complaint of sexual harassment in accordance with the procedure established under subsection (1).

(3) Upon receipt of a complaint of sexual harassment under subsection (2), an employer or any class of employers shall inquire into the complaint in a manner prescribed by the Minister.

(4) Subject to subsection (5), where an employer refuses to inquire into the complaint of sexual harassment as required under subsection (3), he shall, as soon as practicable but in any case not later than thirty days after the date of the receipt of the complaint, inform the complainant of the refusal and the reasons for the refusal in writing.

(5) Notwithstanding subsection (4), an employer may refuse to inquire into any complaint of sexual harassment as required under subsection (3), if:-

(a) the complaint has previously been inquired into andno sexual harassment has been proven; or

(b) the employer is of the opinion that the complaint of sexual harassment is frivolous, vexatious or is not made in good faith.

(6) Any person who is dissatisfied with the refusal of the employer to inquire into his complaint of sexual harassment, may refer the matter to the Director General.

(7) The Director General after reviewing the matter referred to him under subsection (6):-

(a) if he thinks that the matter should be inquired into, direct the employer to conduct an inquiry; or

(b) if he agrees with the decision of the employer not to conduct the inquiry, inform the person who referred the matter to him that no further action will be taken.

Findings of the inquiry by employer

81C. Where the employer conducts an inquiry into a complaint of sexual harassment received under subsection 81B(3) and the employer is satisfied that sexual harassment is proven, the employer shall:-

(a) in the case where the person against whom the complaint of sexual harassment is made is an employee, take disciplinary action which may include the following:

(i) dismissing the employee without notice;

(ii) downgrading the employee; or

(iii) imposing any other lesser punishment as he deems just and fit, and where the punishment of suspension without wages is imposed, it shall not exceed a period of two weeks; and

(b) in the case where the person against whom the complaint of sexual harassment is made is a person other than an employee, recommend that the person be brought before an appropriate disciplinary authority to which the person is subject to.

Complaints of sexual harassment made to the Director General

81D. (1) If a complaint of sexual harassment is made to the Director General, the Director General shall asses the complaint and may direct an employer to inquire into such complaint.

(2) The employer shall inquire into the complaint of sexual harassment when directed to do so under subsection (1) and submit a report of the inquiry to the Director General within thirty days from the date of such direction.

(3) If a complaint of sexual harassment received by the Director General is made against an employer who is a sole proprietor, the Director General shall inquire into such complaint himself in a manner prescribed by the Minister.

Findings of the inquiry by the Director General

81E. (1) Where the inquiry is conducted by the Director General himself under subsection 81D(3) and the Director General is satisfied that sexual harassment is proven, the contract of service between the employer and the complainant may be deemed to be broken.

(2) If a contract of service is deemed to be broken under subsection (1), the complainant is entitled to termination benefits and indemnity provided for under the Act or contract of service, as the case may be.

Offence

81F. Any employer who fails:-

(a) to establish procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment under subsection 81B(1);

(b) to inquire into complaints of sexual harassment under subsection 81B(3);

(c) to inform the complainant of the refusal and the reasons for the refusal as required under subsection 81B(4);

(d) to inquire into complaints of sexual harassment when directed to do so by the Director General under paragraph 81B(7)(a) or subsection 81D(2); or

(e) to submit a report of inquiry into sexual harassment to the Director General under subsection 81D(2),

commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding ten thousand ringgit.

Application of this Part irrespective of wages of employee

81G. Notwithstanding the provisions of this Act, the provisions of this Part extend to every employee employed under a contract of service irrespective of the wages of the employee.".

22. Amendment of section 82

Subsection 82(1) of the principal Act is amended in paragraph (b) of the proviso by deleting the word "male".

23. Amendment of section 86

Section 86 of the principal Act is amended by substituting for the words "section 69" the words "section 69, 69B or 69C".

24. New section 90A

The principal Act is amended by inserting after section 90 the following section:

"Protection of officers

90A. No action shall lie or be brought, instituted or maintained in any court against:-

(a) the Director General, Deputy Director General or any other officer duly appointed under this Act for or on account of or in respect of any act ordered or done for the purpose of carrying this Act into effect; and

(b) any other person for or on account of or in respect of any act done or purported to be done by him under the order, direction or instruction of the Director General, Deputy Director General or any other officer duly appointed under this Act,

if the act was done in good faith and in a reasonable belief that it was necessary for the purpose intended to be served by it.".

25. Amendment of section 92

Paragraph 92(a) of the principal Act is amended by inserting after the words "section 25, 25A," the words "25B,".

26. Amendment of section 101A

Section 101A of the principal Act is amended:-

(a) in subsection (1), by substituting for the words "or a Deputy Director General appointed under paragraph 3(2)(a)" the words ", Deputy Director General or any officer authorized in writing by the Director General";

(b) in subsection (2), by substituting for the words "or the Deputy Director General", wherever they may appear, the words ", Deputy Director General or any officer authorized in writing by the Director General";

(c) in subsection (3), by substituting for the words "or the Deputy Director General" the words ", Deputy Director General or any officer authorized in writing by the Director General"; and

(d) in subsection (5), by substituting for the words "or a Deputy Director General" the words ", Deputy Director General or any officer authorized in writing by the Director General".

27. New section 101B

The principal Act is amended by inserting after section 101A the following section:

"Offence by body corporate, etc.

101B. Where an offence under this Act has been committed by a body corporate, partnership, society or trade union:-

(a) in the case of a body corporate, any person who is a director, manager, or other similar officer of the body corporate at the time of the commission of the offence;

(b) in the case of a partnership, every partner in the partnership at the time of the commission of the offence; and

(c) in the case of a society or trade union, every office bearer of the society or trade union at the time of the commission of the offence,

shall be deemed to have committed the offence and may be charged jointly or severally in the same proceedings as the body corporate, partnership, society or trade union.".

28.Amendment of section 102

Subsection 102(2) of the principal Act is amended:-

(a) in paragraph (i), by substituting for the words "section 69" the words "section 69, 69B or 69C";

(b) in paragraph (j), by substituting for the full stop a semicolon; and

(c) by inserting after paragraph (j) the following paragraphs:

"(k) prescribing the forms of notice and returns of particulars used under section 60K;

(l) prescribing the procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment and the procedure to inquire into such complaints under Part XVA;

(m) prescribing the terms and conditions of service of a domestic servant.".

EXPLANATORY STATEMENT

This Bill seeks to amend the Employment Act 1955 ["Act 265"]. The primary purpose of this Bill is to require the payment of wages of domestic servants to be made into bank accounts of the domestic servants, to provide for the registration of information relating to the supply of employees by a contractor for labour, to require a notice and return of particulars relating to the employment of foreign employees to be submitted and to provide for the establishment of procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment and inquiry into such complaints.

2. Clause 1 contains the short title and the power of the Minister to appoint the commencement date of the proposed Act. Employment (Amendment) 15

3. Clause 2 seeks to amend section 2 of Act 265 to introduce new definitions and to amend certain existing definitions used in Act 265. The definition of "confinement" is amended to enable a pregnant female employee to enjoy maternity protections under Act 265 as early as at twenty-two weeks of pregnancy should the eventualities such as premature births or miscarriages occur. Amongst the new definitions inserted are the definitions of contractor for labour as the person responsible for supply of employees and the definition of sexual harassment for the purpose of the establishment of procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment in the new Part XVA of Act 265.

4. Clause 3 seeks to amend section 4 of Act 265 to include the decisions or orders made under sections 69B and 69C as decisions or orders which cannot be appealed to the Director General by any person affected by such decisions and orders.

5. Clause 5 seeks to amend section 25A of Act 265 to extend the application of the section. With the amendment, the wages of employees can be paid into their bank accounts in any licensed financial institution or institutions approved by Bank Negara Malaysia other than a bank or finance company licensed under the Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989 [Act 372].

6. Clause 6 seeks to introduce a new section 25B into Act 265 to require the employers of domestic servants to pay the wages directly into the bank accounts of their domestic servants unless exempted by the Director General in writing.

7. Clause 9 seeks to introduce a new section 33A into Act 265 to impose a duty on the contractor for labour to register with the Director General in the prescribed form if he intends to supply or undertakes to supply any employee. It also requires a contractor for labour who supplies any employee to keep or maintain information on the employees he supplies in a register and the register shall be made available for inspection. Violations of these requirements are offences under Act 265. The purpose of the introduction of this new section is to monitor the supply of employees by the contractor for labour.

8. Clause 10 seeks to amend section 37 to penalize employers who terminate the service of a female employee during the period in which she is entitled tomaternity leave provided that the termination is not due to retirement, resignation tendered by such employee or the closure of the employer’s business.

9. Clause 11 seeks to amend subsection 40(3) of Act 265 to clarify that no service of a female employee shall be terminated during the period in which she is entitled to maternity leave even though she fails to give notice of her maternity leave as required under subsections 40(1) and (2).

10. Clause 12 seeks to amend section 42 of Act 265 for purpose of clarification.

11. Clause 13 seeks to amend paragraph 60(3)(b) of Act 265 to provide for payment of wages to employees who are paid on a weekly basis for working on a rest day.

12. Clause 14 seeks to amend section 60D of Act 265 to include Malaysia Day which falls on 16 September every year as a mandatory gazetted public holiday on which an employee shall be entitled to a paid holiday at his ordinary rate of pay.

13. Clause 15 seeks to amend section 60I of Act 265 to extend the calculation of the ordinary rate of pay to employees employed on an hourly rate of pay.

14. Clause 16 seeks to amend section 60K of Act 265 to impose a duty on an employer to give notice of his intention to employ foreign employees in the prescribed form to the Director General before employing the foreign employees, and also to furnish further information and particulars regarding the notice to the Director General. The Director General may require an employer to furnish returns of particulars relating to the employment of a foreign employee in such manner as the Director General may direct. Such notice and returns of particulars would assist the Government in monitoring the employment of foreign employees. The proposed amendment would also enable the Labour Department to address the concern over the employment of local job seekers.

15. Clause 17 seeks to amend section 60O of Act 265 to redefine the term of "foreign employee" to exclude domestic servants from the provisions of Part XIIB. This would mean that the requirement for the submission of notice of intention to employ foreign employees to the Director General under section 60K shall not apply in employing domestic servants.

16. Clause 21 seeks to introduce a new Part XVA into Act 265 which deals with complaints of sexual harassment. Section 81A clarifies the meaning of the term "complaint of sexual harassment". Section 81B imposes upon an employer to establish procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment and to inquire into complaints of sexual harassment in a manner prescribed by the Minister. Section 81C deals with findings of the inquiry into complaints of sexual harassment by the employer. Section 81D deals with complaints of sexual harassment which are made directly to the Director General and his findings of the complaints. By virtue of section 81E, if a complaint of sexual harassment is made against an employer who is a sole proprietor, the Director General shall inquire into the complaint himself in a manner prescribed by the Minister. Section 81F deals with offences under this Part whilst section 81G provides that this Part shall apply to all employees irrespective of their wages.

17. Clause 22 seeks to amend section 82 of Act 265 to be in line with the provisions under the Criminal Procedure Code with regards to the service of summons.

18. Clause 23 seeks to amend section 86 of Act 265 consequential upon the proposed amendment made to section 4.

19. Clause 24 seeks to introduce a new section 90A into Act 265 to provide for the protection of officers appointed under this Act from any legal action while carrying out their duties. Employment

20. Clause 25 seeks to amend section 92 of Act 265 to make it an offence if an employer fails to pay the wages of his domestic servant into the domestic servant’s bank account without an exemption in writing from the Director General.

21. Clause 26 seeks to amend section 101A of Act 265 to empower officers other than the Director General and the Deputy Director General to compound any offence committed under this Act, provided that they are authorized in writing by the Director General to do so.

22. Clause 27 seeks to introduce a new section 101B into Act 265 to make directors, managers, partners and trade union office-bearers to be jointly or severally liable for any offences committed by their establishment.

23. Clause 28 seeks to amend section 102 of Act 265 to empower the Minister to make regulations prescribing for matters relating to the employment of foreign employees specifically under section 60K, matters relating to the establishment of procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment and the procedure to inquire into such complaints, and terms and conditions of service of a domestic servant.

24. Other amendments not specifically dealt with in this Statement are minor or consequential in nature.

FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS

This Bill will not involve the Government in any extra financial expenditure.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Report of the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (Malaysia) - 8/2/2011

Below are selected extracts only concerning migrants in Malaysia, for the full report go here

Report of the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention on its Mission to Malaysia (7–17 June 2010) - 8 February 2011

“…Detention under immigration powers does not seem to be in line with international human rights law. The Working Group considers that the detention of migrants should be decided upon by a court of law, on a case-by-case basis, and pursuant to clear and exhaustively defined criteria in legislation under which detention may be used. The Working Group received complaints of detainee abuse, inadequate food, water, medical care and poor sanitation in most immigration detention centres. The situation at the overcrowded Lenggeng detention centre is especially highlighted. The Working Group expresses its concern at the caning of immigrants in an irregular situation and the powers extended to the Ikatan Relawan Rakyat Malaysia (RELA) volunteer force to be present in immigration detention centres and to track down foreigners living in Malaysia without valid documents.

The Working Group also recommends that the Government change its laws and policies related to the detention of asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in an irregular situation, so that detention is decided upon by a court of law, on a case-by-case basis and pursuant to clearly and exhaustively defined criteria; rule out systematic immigration detention of vulnerable groups of migrants; and provide in all cases for automatic periodic review by a court of law on the necessity and legality of detention, as well as an effective remedy for detainees. Lastly, the Working Group recommends that the Government of Malaysia strengthen the status, powers and functions of the national human rights institution SUHAKAM, in accordance with the Paris Principles.”

G. Detention pursuant to immigration powers

65. With regard to detention outside the context of criminal law, during its visit, the Working Group was seriously concerned by the administrative detention regime applied to asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in an irregular situation. In a population of around 28 million, between 3 to 4 million are foreign immigrants. It is estimated that at least half of them are in an irregular situation or without the necessary documentation. Malaysia is a transit point for asylum-seekers, particularly those from Afghanistan and Myanmar. Some 90,000 foreigners have refugee status as determined by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and mainly live in Kuala Lumpur. A significant number of migrants from, inter alia, Bangladesh, Indonesia and Nepal also live in the country without authorization.

66. There is no special legislation relating to refugees and asylum-seekers in Malaysia, since they are not recognized as such under domestic law; indeed, current legislative framework does not even recognize the terms “refugees” and “asylum-seekers”. It is understood that any non-citizens of Malaysia entering the country without the necessary documents and permits are categorized as illegal migrants, dealt with according to the relevant laws and punished accordingly.

67. Illegal migrants are detained under the Immigration Act for the purposes of making inquiries or investigations into an offence under the law, and also for removing from Malaysia any foreigners who violate the provisions under the Act.

68. While immigrants in an irregular situation are subjected to mandatory detention under the Immigration Act, they do have some recourse to a court law. Article 5 of the Federal Constitution provides that detained persons should not be detained for more than 24 hours without authorization by a magistrate, although in the case of immigrants, this period is extended to 14 days. Migrants are detained by order of the Director General of Immigration and, under the criminal Procedure Code, by a magistrate. Detention of migrants in a prison is governed by the Prisons Regulations (2000), which contain safeguards on fundamental liberties, inter alia the rights to food, clothing, medical examination and treatment, education and recreation, the right to visits and communication.

69. The Government has not ratified the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees or the Protocol thereto. The Government has yet to put in place a national legal and administrative framework for dealing with asylum-seekers and refugees. While the Government does not restrict the access of undetained asylum-seekers to the Office of UNCHR, it does nothing to facilitate access and, as part of its immigration enforcement efforts, often arrests and detains asylum-seekers and refugees.

70. Although Malaysia is not a party to the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the Protocol thereto, Malaysia has fulfilled its international obligations to persons who have entered Malaysia claiming to be refugees and asylum-seekers through special arrangements on humanitarian grounds with UNHCR.

71. Persons committing offences under the immigration laws (either travelling without travel documents or committing criminal offences) are detained by the relevant authorities. However, section 8 (3) of the Immigration Act 1959/63 also sets out to determine persons categorized and prohibited from entering Malaysia. In the event, however, that such offenders are from vulnerable groups, including minors, families with minor children, pregnant women, elderly persons, persons with disabilities and other such persons, the authorities are required, on the basis of humanitarian grounds, to take all reasonable measures to treat such persons with appropriate care and attention.

72. The Working Group believes that detention of migrants should be decided upon by a court of law, on a case-by-case basis, and pursuant to clearly and exhaustively defined criteria in legislation under which detention may be used. The Government should not use immigration detention for asylum-seekers, refugees and vulnerable groups of migrants, including unaccompanied minors, families with minor children, pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, or people with serious and/or chronic physical or mental health problems.

73. In all cases, immigrants should be provided with automatic periodic review by a court of law of the necessity and legality of their detention at any time.

74. Refugees and asylum-seekers are prosecuted for immigration-related offences and may be indefinitely detained at immigration detention centres or deported. Malaysia has no laws or regulations relating to the status of refugees and asylum-seekers in line with international standards. The 24 hours allowed for the police to bring a detainee before a magistrate becomes 2 weeks in the case of a foreigner detained under immigration laws.

75. In the absence of national refugee legislation, UNHCR performs core protection functions, including registration of asylum-seekers, determination of refugee status, issuance of identification documentation and promotion of solutions, including voluntary return, local integration or resettlement in a third country. UNHCR performs these functions, however, as a result of the Government’s unwillingness to perform what are clearly State functions of asylum management. UNHCR does so in the absence of a comprehensive legal and administrative framework for managing asylum-seekers.

76. The Government believes that the issue of refugees and asylum-seekers requires commitments from all States to cooperate in addressing the problems of the mass influx of refugees and asylum-seekers faced by many countries, including Malaysia. Such commitments would need to take into account the resources available of each State and their relevant domestic laws and migration policies. States should take measures jointly to eliminate the problems that give rise to persons having to migrate from their country of origin. Apart from addressing the issue of refugees, efforts need to be made to assist the countries of origin to alleviate the root causes of why their people migrate to other countries; only then would the international community to be able address the problem of refugees and migration as a whole.

77. The capacity of the 13 immigration detention centres in the country is around 6,000 places. All centres are under the control of the Immigration Department. Approximately 10,000 people were deported in 2009.

78. The Government is working to address the issue of overcrowding, the number of detainees has been reduced to an average of 4,500 to 4,800 from the total capacity of 6,640 of all detention centres. Cooperation with non-governmental organizations and international bodies is vital to improve management of immigration detention centres. The Government is therefore working closely with the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) and organizations such as Buddhist and Shelter.

79. The Government recognized that there is a need to improve conditions in immigration detention centres. It is taking steps such as by establishing a new set-up comprising personnel from various departments. The Government is also currently looking at emulating best practices in detention centre management of other countries such as Australia and the Netherlands. An additional allocation of RM100 million was recently approved by the Government to upgrade physical conditions and renovations of the centres concerned.

80. The Working Group was informed that at least six asylum-seekers and migrants had died of leptospirosis, an infectious disease, in immigration detention camps. In 2009, 14 detainees died in immigration detention centres.

81. Capacity at Lenggeng detention centre is 1,250, including a block for 250 women. As a transit place, detainees should stay for a maximum of 14 days for investigation. The Working Group found evidence of overcrowding, insufficient access to potable water, poor sanitation and inadequate medical care. Allegations were received of inadequate food and lack of ventilation. The unsanitary and overcrowded conditions facilitated the transmission of communicable diseases, particularly skin diseases. Three detainees died during the first five months of 2010. Some detainees also stated that the overcrowding often led to confrontations and fighting between the detainees, with very limited or no intervention at all from the security guards.

82. The Working Group found a 14-year-old boy who had been in the centre since June 2008. He stated that he was born in Malaysia, although his documents indicated that he was Indonesian, as both his parents are Indonesian. He was adopted by a Malaysian family after his parents returned to Indonesia in 2006. His adoptive family had not visited him since 2009. He has no bed in his cell and was uncertain about his future.

83. According to the Government, all immigrants are subject to the same criminal justice system in Malaysia; detainees may therefore challenge the necessity and legality of their detention at any time. This is a common principle of the criminal justice system in Malaysia. Migrants who are found in an irregular situation (without valid travel documents) or commit an offence are charged in court. After the sentence period has been served, migrants are kept in immigration detention centres until deportation. The Working Group reminds the Government that it is an obligation of the State to guarantee the right to safety of all foreigners when it decides to place them in detention.

84. In Sabah, concern was also expressed at the detention of foreign children whose parents had been deported.

85. Migrants found to have violated immigration laws are liable to imprisonment, substantial fines and, in some cases, caning. Since 2002, caning has been used to punish immigration offences, such as illegally entering the country. The Working Group was informed that most of the 10,000 people caned each year are immigrants in an irregular situation.

86. Upon the conclusion of its visit, the Working Group was informed that no migrant in detention was denied the necessary medical treatment.

V. Conclusions

92. Most prisons visited were found to meet international standards and regulations on conditions. This finding does not, however, apply to immigration detention centres.

100. The regime applied to migrants in an irregular situation, refugees and asylum seekers is not seen to be in line with international human rights law. Immigrants in an irregular situation arriving in the country are subjected to mandatory detention without genuine recourse to a court of law. The conditions of detention at most of the immigration detention centres visited adversely affect the ability of detainees to challenge the lawfulness of their detention. The Working Group received complaints of detainee abuse, inadequate food, water and medical care, and poor sanitation in the immigration detention centres.

101. The Working Group expresses its concern about the excessive powers granted to the non-official organization RELA, particularly its activities concerning asylum seekers, refugees and migrants in an irregular situation. The Working Group received allegations of ill-treatment and beatings by RELA militants.

103. The Working Group further expresses its concerns about the situation of overcrowding in prisons, but mainly in immigration detention centres.

A. General recommendations

105. The Government should increase its efforts to develop a human rights culture in Malaysia. The judiciary should train magistrates, judges and prosecutors in international human rights law in order to increase the capacity of applying international human rights principles and standards in the resolution of judicial cases.

106. The Government should become a party to the main international instruments on human rights, particularly the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the Protocol thereto, the Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, the Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.

107. The Government should also study the possibility of becoming a party to the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families and the Optional Protocol thereto, as well as of revising the reservations and declarations it made to those conventions to which it is a State party.

C. Concerning detention under immigration powers

117. Regardless of immigration status, nobody should be subjected to arbitrary detention or appalling detention conditions. The Government is reminded that it is its responsibility to guarantee the right to physical and psychological integrity and the right to security in immigration detention centres.

118. The Government should ratify the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the Protocol thereto, and put in place a national legal and administrative framework for dealing with asylum-seekers and refugees that meets international standards.

119. The Government should also rule out detention of asylum-seekers and refugees

as well as vulnerable groups of migrants, including unaccompanied minors, families with minor children, pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, people with serious and/or chronic physical or mental health problems.

120. The Government should, in all cases, provide for automatic periodic review by a court of law on the necessity and legality of detention.

121. The Government should also provide for an effective remedy for detainees to challenge the necessity and legality of detention at any time of the detention period and ex post facto, and define the circumstances.

122. As long as there is a regime of mandatory administrative detention for migrants in an irregular situation, the Government should legally define its maximum period rather than basing it on Government regulations or policy.

123. The Government should also provide for a system of legal aid for immigration detainees.

124. The Government should assume the responsibility of improving the conditions in immigration detention centres as a matter of urgency.

125. RELA, as a volunteer force, should not be used for law enforcement nor for guarding immigration detention centres.